Five Ways to Silence Your Inner Critic While Drafting

Those of us just starting out on our writing journeys can sometimes get bogged down by inner doubts. The worst critic is the one living inside your own head, available with scathing retorts on a relentless, 24/7 schedule.

For many of us who are working on a first draft, this can spell disaster. The inner critic’s time must come, but that time is at a later stage, when you’re revising.

But for now, you have one task at hand. It is your only essential task. Your task is to write.

And to do so, you need to slay your inner critic – or at the very least, mute them – so that you can get out from what Andy Weir calls tyranny of the blank page and have something to show for your brilliant ideas!

5 ways to silence your inner critic while drafting:

#1 – Give your inner critic a name and face them down directly to get them to hush

If your inner critic has always felt formidable, name them something worthy of their power. For example, I’ve named mine The Naysayer, which makes me…wait for it…The Naysayer Slayer! On the other hand, you might consider a goofy name to make your inner critic a little less intimidating, like Oscar the Inner Grouch, or Fussy McGee. A sample conversation could go something like:

Fussy McGee: That was the worst sentence I’ve ever read in my life!

You: Pipe down, Fussy McGee, and get out of my way! I have a draft to finish and you’re not helping.

#2 – Say your affirmations out loud

Some of my favorite affirmations are: 

“I am more than my inner critic.” 
“I refuse to be my own worst enemy.” 
“Critique comes later. Now, it’s time to write!”

#3 – Schedule a time to let out your inner critic for a short while

We recommend doing this no more than every week or two. Create a recurring appointment on your calendar that lets you sit down with your inner critic and hear them out. Many times, your inner critic is needlessly disruptive to your drafting process, but sometimes, that niggling voice inside of your head is onto something that might help unblock you if you take time to listen. Use the following template to guide your critic, so you don’t go off the rails into destructive, never-ending hand-wringing:

What specific pages or concept am I going to critique during this session?
What do I dislike about my project?
What do I actually like or even love about it?
Is there a way I can achieve my broader writing goal in a different way than I’ve already done in these pages/using this concept? If yes, how might I do this? If no, how might I modify what I already have to achieve my goal?

Think out loud and document your critic’s comments. You can create a video of yourself thinking out loud, or make an audio recording on your phone, or jot down your notes in a document.

Finally – and this is important – end the meeting with your inner critic on time. If you’ve set aside 60 minutes to hear out your inner critic, spend only 60 minutes doing so. Then step away from critique mode to do something nice for yourself, or if you’re so inclined, even jump back into drafting. 

#4 – Leave the critiquing part to other readers

Many times, our inner critic may pick up on something that can be useful to us…but maybe they won’t! If you’re finding yourself going in circles trying to do your own critique, then put your messy draft in front of other readers. Feedback from other readers is always surprising. Two things will happen: 

1) They will love things that you thought they would hate, or things you didn’t even think about! One of my favorite experiences during the writing process is hearing from a reader that they loved a turn of phrase or a detail that I just hastily typed out and didn’t think about twice.

2) You will find readers will be confused by plot points or character developments that you yourself thought were really simple. Other readers will notice all kinds of things you can choose to revise at a later stage. But for now, the task at hand is your draft, which is begging to see the light of day. Give your draft the gift that it deserves by bringing it into the world, inner critic be damned!

#5 – Attend a weekly in-person writing session with other focused writers

This is a great way to temporarily silence your inner critic, because you’re surrounded by other writers who are busy scribbling or typing away, which makes you want to do the same.

If you haven’t already, attend one of the weekly Shut Up & Write! events scheduled in your area. If one isn’t nearby, start one of your own by visiting shutupwrite.com/organizers.

Remember – the most important thing is to get words on the page. Critique, revision, editing, publishing, and best-selling fame all come later, after you have something to show to peers or editors or agents. Learning how to silence your inner critic for just enough time to make progress on your project by actually writing is a skill well worth practicing!

Published by Lira

Lira writes speculative fiction and is currently at work on her first novel. Follow her on Twitter at @lirawrites and Instagram at @lirawrites

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Find Your Chapter

Browse Chapters